Mine planning tools answer a geometric question very well: which blocks get mined, in what sequence, and when ore reaches the plant. The harder question is whether the shovels, trucks, crushers, and maintenance crews assigned to that plan can actually deliver it once queues, breakdowns, and lengthening haul routes come into play. When they can’t, the shortfall usually appears after the fleet is bought and the budget is approved. MISIM closes that gap with simulation-based digital twins that run your mine plan against real equipment behavior, so mine planning decisions on fleet size, capital timing, and production targets are tested before they are locked in.

MISIM is a simulation modeling and digital twin consulting firm based in North Vancouver, British Columbia. Our team includes INFORMS Franz Edelman Laureates, and we work directly with owners, study managers, and engineering teams on major mining capital and operating decisions around the world, including production models of record for major mining projects.

→ Is your current mine plan resting on fleet numbers nobody has tested against queues and downtime? Contact MISIM to talk through what a mine planning simulation would reveal before your next budget cycle.

Why Does a Mine Plan Look Achievable on Paper but Fall Short in the Pit?

Most mine planning starts in a scheduling platform such as Deswik, Vulcan, or MinePlan. Those tools are excellent at what they were built for: pit and stope design, block sequencing, grade blending, and period-by-period tonnage targets. Equipment requirements are then estimated by dividing scheduled tonnes by an expected productivity per shovel or truck, adjusted for availability and utilization.

That calculation runs on averages. An average truck cycle time, an average dig rate, an average mechanical availability. Each number can be reasonable on its own. The trouble is that a mine never runs at its averages. Trucks bunch up at the shovel and then leave it idle. Two loaders go down for maintenance in the same week. A ramp gets longer as the pit deepens, and a fleet sized for year two is still running in year six.

These effects compound. A short stoppage at the primary crusher backs trucks up at the dump. Longer queues stretch cycle times, shovels wait for trucks, and the shift misses its tonnes. No single input in the spreadsheet changed, yet the plan fell short.

Consider an illustrative case. A mine plan calls for a fixed annual tonnage from three shovels and a truck fleet sized on average cycle times for the year-three haul profile. By year five the main ramp is two benches deeper, the waste dump has moved farther out, and two trucks are in the workshop for scheduled rebuilds at the same time. The spreadsheet still shows the fleet as adequate. A simulation of the same mine planning period shows shovels waiting on trucks for a large share of each shift, and the operation falling behind plan well before year end.

Peer-reviewed research points to the same problem. A study in the Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy found that material handling accounts for about 50% of production costs in open pit mining, and that deterministic, stochastic, and experimental approaches to truck and shovel sizing produce considerably different results (Dindarloo, Osanloo, and Frimpong, 2015). When the largest cost line in the operation depends on which method was used to size it, the choice of method deserves scrutiny.

For mine managers and capital planning teams, the consequence is practical. Mine planning that relies only on static equipment calculations tends to miss in one of two directions. Either the fleet is undersized and production falls behind, or extra trucks and loaders are bought as a buffer and capital sits idle. Both outcomes cost money, and both can be avoided when the plan is tested against equipment behavior before the purchase orders go out.

What Equipment Constraints Does Conventional Mine Planning Miss?

Before explaining how MISIM approaches the problem, it helps to be specific about where static mine planning loses accuracy. Across open pit and underground operations, the same constraints come up again and again.

Trucks and loaders rarely meet at a steady rhythm. Match factor calculations assume trucks arrive at a loading unit evenly spaced. In practice they arrive in bunches, so queues form at the shovel and then the shovel waits for the next truck. Averaged cycle times hide both losses.

Availability percentages say nothing about timing. A planned availability of 85% does not tell you when the other 15% happens. Component change-outs run in campaigns, planned shutdowns overlap, and unplanned failures ignore the schedule. When downtime lands often matters more than how much of it there is over a year.

Haul profiles change with every plan period. Faces, dumps, and ramps move as the pit advances. Haul distances, grades, and travel times move with them. A fleet that comfortably supports one phase can fall short in the next, even when scheduled tonnage stays flat.

Crushers and dumps are shared by everyone. A primary crusher, a tipping point, or a ROM reclaim position serves several loading units at once. When the crusher stops, every loaded truck heading there is affected, and the loss spreads back to the face.

Operating rules eat into effective hours. Shift changes, blast clearances, refueling, weather, road maintenance, and dispatch priorities all reduce productive time in ways a single utilization factor struggles to capture.

Underground equipment competes for access. Development headings, jumbos, loaders, orepasses, ventilation limits, and hoisting slots all compete for the same space and time. A development sequence that looks feasible in the schedule can stall once equipment and access constraints are applied together.

Mine planning platforms remain the right tools for designing and sequencing the mine. Simulation adds a test they were never built to run: whether the equipment assigned to the plan can deliver it, how often it will fall short, and which constraint is responsible. Those losses also travel downstream, which is why so much hidden capacity across the mine value chain is found at the interfaces between the pit, the plant, and logistics.

→ Has a recent plan period fallen short even though the fleet looked adequate in the schedule? Contact MISIM to find out which equipment constraint is actually governing your production.

How Does MISIM Test Whether Mine Planning Holds Up Against Real Equipment?

MISIM builds a discrete-event simulation model that sits alongside your existing mine planning tools. It takes the plan as your team has written it and runs it truck by truck and shift by shift against the equipment, operating rules, and variability of the real operation. Here is how a typical engagement runs.

Step 1: Define the Decision and the Value at Risk

Every MISIM mine planning engagement begins by pinning down the decision the model has to support and what is at stake if that decision is wrong. It might be how many haul trucks to buy for a pit expansion, whether a second primary crusher is justified, or whether a feasibility study’s production basis is defensible. The decision sets the model scope. We favor the smallest credible model that can answer the question, and expand the boundary only when the answer depends on something outside it.

Step 2: Work From the Mine Plan as It Exists

We take your schedules, pit and dump designs, haul networks, equipment lists, and maintenance plans, whether they come from Deswik, Vulcan, MinePlan, or a well-kept spreadsheet. Your planners keep using the tools they know. MISIM tests the output and leaves ownership of the planning process with the team responsible for it.

Step 3: Model Equipment the Way It Actually Behaves

The model represents individual shovels, loaders, trucks, crushers, and support units, each with its own cycle time distributions, failure and repair patterns, maintenance schedule, and operating rules. Haul routes update period by period as the plan advances. Queues, blocking, and starvation come out of the interactions between equipment instead of being assumed in a utilization factor. This is usually where the mine planning spreadsheet and the simulation start to disagree, and that disagreement is often the most useful finding of the study.

Step 4: Validate Before Anyone Relies on the Results

A model that has not been checked against reality should not inform a capital decision. For operating mines, MISIM calibrates against historical dispatch, production, and maintenance records. For greenfield projects, we use vendor data, benchmarks from comparable operations, and structured review by subject matter experts. Mine planners, maintenance leads, and operations staff review the logic until they recognize their own operation in it. This step sits at the center of MISIM’s DIVES methodology (Define, Implement, Validate, Evaluate, Synthesize), and it is where a model earns the right to be used.

Step 5: Test Scenarios Across the Life of the Plan

Once validated, the model runs each mine planning period many times to capture variability. We compare fleet sizes, purchase timing, dispatch rules, maintenance strategies, crusher arrangements, and plan alternatives side by side. Operating variability and uncertainty in the project basis are different problems, so MISIM tests them separately. The resulting production range reflects what could happen as well as what usually happens.

Step 6: Translate Results Into Decision Evidence

The output is a set of answers leadership can act on: an achievable production range (P10, P50, and P90) for each mine planning period, a ranking of the constraints that cost the most tonnes, the fleet and equipment changes that close the gap, and the capital that can be deferred or avoided. Results are presented so that an executive committee, a study manager, and an independent engineer can each follow the reasoning.

→ Would your mine plan survive a truck-by-truck test of the equipment assigned to it? Contact MISIM to scope a simulation around the decision your team needs to make.

What Makes MISIM Different for Mine Planning Decisions?

Plenty of teams can build a simulation model, and many mining companies have tried one through an equipment vendor or an internal analytics group. MISIM specializes in models that hold up when a major capital or operating decision depends on them. In mine planning work, that standard shows up in five specific ways.

Senior practitioners lead every engagement. MISIM’s founder has more than 30 years of experience modeling mining, processing, and logistics systems, and the team includes INFORMS Franz Edelman Laureates. The people scoping your model have built production models of record for major mining projects and know where mine plans tend to break.

Models are built to be challenged. Assumptions are documented, logic is open to review, and results can be reproduced. MISIM expects engineering, operations, finance, and independent reviewers to push hard on the model, and builds it so they can.

The pit stays connected to everything downstream. Equipment constraints rarely stay in the mine. MISIM can extend a mine planning model into crushing, stockpiles, processing, rail, and port operations, so a fleet decision is judged by its effect on total system output instead of tonnes moved at the face. Questions about crusher and stockpile sizing often turn into broader simulation-based capacity planning once the whole chain is in view.

Variability and uncertainty are handled separately. Running the same assumptions hundreds of times measures operating variability. Finding out whether those assumptions are right takes a separate test. MISIM evaluates credible alternatives for equipment reliability, productivity, and ore characteristics, which gives sanction and financing teams a more honest production range.

Value is measured at the decision. Work by MISIM’s team has been credited with more than $300 million in client savings, including major capital that was deferred because the model showed it was not yet needed. The same discipline applies when de-risking capital investment decisions on truck fleets, crushers, and pit expansions.

→ Does your next feasibility study or expansion case need a production basis that can stand up to independent review? Contact MISIM to discuss what a decision-grade model would add.

Which Mine Planning Decisions Can MISIM Help You Test?

MISIM’s mining work clusters around a set of high-consequence questions. If one of these is on your desk, a simulation study is likely to pay for itself many times over.

Fleet sizing and purchase timing. How many trucks does each plan period really need, and when should the next units arrive? Buying a year early ties up capital, and buying a year late costs production. Testing fleet options against changing haul profiles turns a mine planning rule of thumb into a purchase schedule. The same thinking applies to allocating shared equipment and crews across pits, shifts, and maintenance bays.

Loader and truck matching. Mixed fleets, a new truck class, or a change of loading unit alters queueing at every face. Simulation shows the effect on cycle times and productivity before anything is ordered.

Crusher, dump, and stockpile capacity. Whether a second crusher, a larger ROM pad, or a different reclaim strategy is justified depends on how often trucks are blocked and how much that blocking costs, which a model can quantify directly.

Maintenance strategy. Moving component change-outs, adding a workshop bay, or staggering shutdowns can recover tonnes without buying another truck. MISIM tests these options against the production schedule they affect.

New phases, pushbacks, and expansions. Each new phase changes haul distances and ramp traffic. Testing the mine planning sequence before the phase starts shows whether the existing fleet can keep up and when it will stop being able to.

Technology changes. Autonomous haulage, trolley assist, battery-electric equipment, and new dispatch logic all change cycle times, charging or service needs, and traffic rules. Simulation tests whether the expected gain survives contact with your operation.

Feasibility and sanction studies. For greenfield projects, MISIM tests whether the mine plan, fleet, and plant together support the production basis in the financial model, and what range of outcomes is defensible in front of a board or lender.

Comparing several of these options side by side is where scenario planning with simulation earns its place in a study schedule.

→ Is a fleet purchase, crusher upgrade, or new pit phase waiting on a decision your team can’t yet justify with confidence? Contact MISIM and we’ll show you how a model would answer it.

How MISIM Supports Mine Planning Teams Beyond a Single Study

A mine planning model is most valuable when it stays in use after the first decision. MISIM offers four connected solutions, and mining clients often draw on more than one.

Digital twins and simulation form the core: a validated model of your operation, built around a specific decision using your own data.

Through MISIM’s simulation consulting, our team runs the analysis with you, frames scenarios alongside your planners, and presents findings to leadership, study reviewers, and partners.

With model custodianship, MISIM keeps the model current as the mine plan, fleet, and operating data change. The model can then support each budget cycle and life-of-mine update instead of going stale after one study, and mine planning and simulation stay in step.

Independent model audits give owners a second opinion on an existing simulation or capacity model, whether it was built internally, by an engineering firm, or by an equipment supplier, before it informs a major commitment.

Mine planning and mining operations are MISIM’s deepest area of experience, covering open pit and underground operations, potash, copper and gold, lithium, and oil sands. Equipment constraints in the pit connect to the rail lines, ports, and terminals that carry product to market, so MISIM’s work in those sectors, along with oil and gas, shapes how its mine-to-market models are built. Examples from these industries are on MISIM’s case studies page. MISIM works directly with owners and engineering teams on capital and operating decisions globally, so location is rarely a barrier to an engagement.

→ Is a model your team built two years ago still driving decisions nobody has rechecked? Contact MISIM about an independent audit or ongoing custodianship.

Mine Planning with MISIM: FAQs

How does MISIM test whether a mine plan holds up against equipment constraints?

MISIM builds a discrete-event simulation of your operation that runs the mine plan period by period with individual trucks, loaders, crushers, and maintenance events. Queues, breakdowns, changing haul routes, and operating rules are all represented, so the model shows the production the equipment can actually deliver, how often each period falls short, and which constraint causes the loss.

Does MISIM replace mine planning software like Deswik, Vulcan, or MinePlan?

No. Those platforms remain the right tools for designing and scheduling the mine. MISIM uses their outputs as inputs and adds a test they were not designed to run: whether the assigned equipment can deliver the schedule under realistic variability. Your planners keep their workflow, and MISIM feeds results back so the next round of mine planning reflects what the equipment can achieve.

What data does MISIM need to start a mine planning simulation?

Typically the mine schedule, pit or stope and dump designs, haul road network, equipment list with specifications, and maintenance strategy. For operating mines, dispatch, production, and maintenance records allow MISIM to calibrate the model against actual performance. For greenfield projects, MISIM works with vendor data, study assumptions, and benchmarks. Gaps in the data are documented and tested as part of the analysis rather than hidden.

How does MISIM validate a mine planning model before it informs a capital decision?

MISIM checks the model against historical performance where it exists, reviews logic and assumptions with your planners, maintenance leads, and operations staff, and tests results against independent calculations. Assumptions are documented so finance teams and outside reviewers can trace how each result was produced. A model is only used for a decision once the people who run the operation agree it behaves like their mine.

Can MISIM model underground as well as open pit mine planning?

Yes. MISIM has modeled open pit truck and shovel systems, underground development and production, hoisting, and the processing and logistics systems connected to both. Underground models typically represent development headings, mobile equipment, orepasses, ventilation or access limits, and hoisting capacity, since those shared constraints often decide whether a development sequence is achievable.

How long does a MISIM mine planning simulation project take?

Timing depends on the decision and the scope. A focused question about fleet size for one pit phase needs a much smaller model than an integrated pit-to-port model supporting a feasibility study. MISIM sets the scope around the decision during the first conversations and gives you a schedule tied to your study or budget milestones, so results arrive before the decision has to be made. On study work, model deliverables are aligned with study gates, so the production basis is tested before the engineering design and the capital estimate are frozen.

Can MISIM keep a mine planning model current after the first study?

Yes. Through model custodianship, MISIM updates the model as the mine plan, fleet, maintenance data, and operating rules change. A maintained model can then test each budget cycle, life-of-mine update, and expansion option, which avoids rebuilding the analysis from scratch whenever a new question comes up.

How does MISIM price a mine planning simulation engagement?

Pricing follows the decision being supported and the scope needed to support it. The best starting point is a short conversation about the decision in front of you and the value at risk, such as the cost of a fleet purchase or the production at stake in an expansion. MISIM then proposes the smallest credible model that can answer the question, with a clear scope and fee.

Mine Planning with MISIM

A mine plan is only as good as the equipment’s ability to deliver it. Averages and utilization factors give a starting estimate, but they cannot show how queues, downtime, shared crushers, and longer hauls interact over the life of a plan.

MISIM tests mine planning against the way equipment really behaves, then turns the results into production ranges, constraint rankings, and capital recommendations your leadership and reviewers can trust. That means a fleet sized for the plan you intend to mine, and capital spent when the operation actually needs it.

→ Ready to find out whether your mine plan holds up before the next fleet purchase or study gate? Contact MISIM to discuss the decision in front of you.

Published

You might also like…

Follow us to learn some of the keys to successful simulation modeling to maximize business potential.

View All Articles